Mahogany Rose is a gorgeous, young go-getter and overachiever who has had high moral standards her entire life and a somewhat whimsical idea of how her love life would turn out. But when she meets Kaleb Myles, a charming and charismatic man who checks off nearly all her boxes, she’s forced to reconsider her typical standards as she discovers that he falls short of a critical characteristic on her list — being single. With the help of her friends — Misha Taylor, a teacher who works hard and plays even harder; Reign Moore, a recently cut off trust-funder forced to find alternative revenue to pay the bills; and Shyra Clemons, a grad student who believes she has found the perfect man — Mahogany must decide if she will stick to her preference of being the one and only or step out of her comfort zone and learn to play number two.